Tuesday, July 13, 2010

"Hand shuffle"

There still remain a few bits of poker room procedure that I don't fully understand, even after more hours with my butt in chairs in those rooms than I would want to count up.

Here's one: In some poker rooms, but by no means all, when a dealer is doing the shuffle by hand instead of using the machine, he or she calls out, "Hand shuffle, table 6."

What is the purpose of alerting the floor to a hand shuffle? I don't know. My guess has long been that it was to help prevent fraud in high-hand and/or bad-beat jackpots. You know how dealers will tap a toke on a hard surface before pocketing it. The idea behind that is that somebody stealing a chip is not going to call attention to it. I have assumed that it's that same general idea for the hand shuffle--a dealer who is attempting to set the deck in order to achieve some otherwise highly unlikely outcome will not want to call attention to the fact that he is doing so. Thus, alerting the floor to the procedure brings it more out in the open and thus makes it less suspicious.

That theory was confounded today, however, when I noticed the dealers at MGM Grand doing it--a poker room that has no jackpots. (They've probably been doing it all along, and it just never before sunk into my skull that this doesn't fit my theory.) Of course, the same principle could apply to an ordinary hand, just making sure that the dealer isn't putting out a cold deck to the advantage of some particular player.

But I really don't know the answer, and today I am wondering if my previous assumption was all wrong. Fortunately, there are several excellent, knowledgeable dealers among my readers, and I'm confident that one or more of them will speak up in the comments section and satisfy our collective curiosity. (After all, I can't be the only one who has wondered about this, can I?)

4 comments:

Matthew Yauch said...

Stupid procedure, but pretty sure it's an accountability thing to make sure the dealer isn't cheating, just like the tip tap. Don't think I've ever witnessed someone announce it, most places the dealer just shuffles and gets on with it.

Auto shufflers enjoy jamming on you, and a couple of times I got tired of the little red button so I just stopped using it at that table. I'm 100% against shufflers since not only do they mark the cards but I can shuffle as quickly as I can wait for the door to open and swap decks out of the shuffler.

There are plenty of places that don't use auto shufflers and they get by just fine without calling "hand shuffle" every hand.

Anonymous said...

To let the floor person know that the shuffler is on the fritz.

Grange95 said...

A related quirky rule is in force at the local casino. If there is a misdeal, the dealer must wait for the auto-shuffler; if hand-shuffled, the hand is ineligible for any jackpot (bad beat and high hands). However, if the hand is played out and completed before the auto-shuffler is ready (folds to the blinds who chop, or a raise takes it down preflop), the dealer is permitted to hand shuffle with all jackpots eligible.

Crazy.

Pete said...

Though I have seen some procedures that say you should do this I have never done it myself, and even though it is probably in the rules somewhere I have worked I have never noticed my coworkers doing this or any supervisor caring about it.

I suspect the rule most likely originaly came from someone more familiar with "Pit practices" where shuffles in games are always announced (and I even see dealers shuffling decks before putting them in shufflers in some pits) and hand shuffles are never allowed on a pit game with malfunctioning machine.

Like many rules once it gets into someones rulebook it gets copied and emulated even if there is no reason for the rule (I routinely see rules in rule books which are the exact opposite of the actual rule)